FollowingSign in

What are prediction markets, and how do they work?

By MumblesFacts checked on 10 min read

The short answer

A prediction market is a site where you bet on how future events turn out, such as a game or an election, against other people rather than a house. A share pays $1 if you're right and nothing if you're wrong, so its price reads as the market's chance: 25¢ means 25%. In the US, the CFTC, a federal agency, regulates them, but some states say they're gambling.

What is a prediction market?

A prediction market is a place where people bet on how future events turn out. Each market asks a question, and people buy and sell shares in the answers.

In the United States, the CFTC (Commodity Futures Trading Commission), a government agency, regulates them. It calls what people trade there event contracts.

Kalshi compares itself with a stock exchange. On the New York Stock Exchange, you buy shares that make you part owner of a company. On a prediction market, you trade contracts on whether an event will happen, such as "Will interest rates rise in the next quarter?"

The CFTC says some people use them to cover a real risk, like a citrus farmer who fears a sudden freeze. Others use them to try to make money by taking a risk.

How do prediction markets work?

Markets often ask a Yes or No question. You buy Yes if you think it will happen, or No if you think it won't. The CFTC says the payout is fixed, usually $1, and each contract ends at a set time or when the event is over.

Kalshi calls what you buy a contract. Polymarket calls it a share. Either way, it pays $1 if you're right. If you're wrong, it's worth nothing.

The price is between $0 and $1, and it moves as people buy and sell. It reads as the market's chance that the answer comes true. Polymarket's docs give the examples: 25¢ means a 25% chance, and 75¢ means 75%.

Polymarket says it doesn't set the prices: they come from what traders will pay. Kalshi pairs a Yes buyer with a No buyer, and together they put in $1. So in Kalshi's example, if Yes costs 70¢, No costs 30¢.

Here's an example with our own sums. Say Yes costs 25¢ and No costs 75¢. You put $10 on Yes, which buys you 40 shares.

Your betIf Yes winsIf No wins
40 Yes shares at 25¢, for $10You get $40: a $30 profitYou get $0: a $10 loss
40 No shares at 75¢, for $30You get $0: a $30 lossYou get $40: a $10 profit

The side the market thinks is less likely costs less, and it gains more if it wins. These sums leave out fees.

Your profit on a winning share is $1 minus the price you paid, before fees.

You don't have to wait for the end. You can sell your shares before the market is decided, as long as someone wants to buy them. You get the best price a buyer offers, which can be a little below the price you see.

Who you bet against, and how prediction markets make money

You bet against other people, not against the site. Kalshi says you always trade against another member, not the exchange itself. Polymarket says you trade with other users, not against a "house". The CFTC says the exchanges it regulates don't take a side of the trade.

Kalshi says most of its traders are retail traders, meaning everyday people rather than institutions.

The sites charge fees on trades. Here's what each one says:

  • Kalshi says it makes money from fees on trades, not from which way the result goes.
  • polymarket.com charges a small fee on most kinds of market, but only on an order that fills at once. It says it takes no fee and makes no profit on geopolitics markets.
  • Polymarket US also charges a fee on an order that fills at once.

France's National Gambling Authority (ANJ) says direct or indirect fees on trades are the main source of revenue for most prediction markets.

And you? You make money if your side wins, or if you sell your shares for more than you paid. Polymarket's own example: you buy Yes at 18¢, and it wins. Each share is now worth $1, so you make 82¢ on each share, before fees.

What can you bet on?

Here are the groups that Kalshi and Polymarket list, with examples from their own pages:

  • Sports: the NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB, MLS, college sports, tennis, golf and more.
  • Politics: elections, big court cases and new laws.
  • Economics: interest rates, unemployment and recessions.
  • Culture: the Oscars, the Grammys and the Billboard Hot 100.
  • Weather: natural disasters and other weather events.
  • Companies and tech: how many cars Tesla delivers in a quarter, and which AI model leads at the end of the year.
  • Crypto and world events: polymarket.com has groups for crypto and geopolitics.

Not every market is one Yes or No question. The CFTC says some join several Yes or No contracts into one, some offer multiple choices, and some pay out in part for a range of results.

The biggest prediction markets: Kalshi and Polymarket

France's ANJ says two players led prediction markets in 2025: Polymarket and Kalshi. Polymarket comes in two separate versions, so there are three to know:

SiteWho it's for, the site saysRegulated by the CFTC?
KalshiPeople in the US and in many other countries. Some US states limit it.Yes, since 3rd November 2020
polymarket.comPeople outside the US, except in blocked countries and regionsNo, Polymarket says
Polymarket USPeople in the USYes, its exchange since 9th July 2025

Kalshi says you can use it from many countries outside the US, but not from all of them. Reuters reports that at least four US states, among them Nevada and Michigan, have won court orders that limit what Kalshi can offer there. Our post on how Kalshi works walks you through Kalshi. To see what Kalshi's top traders are betting on, open our Kalshi leaderboard. It's free, and you don't need a login.

polymarket.com is Polymarket's international, crypto-based site. Its list of blocked countries includes the US, the United Kingdom, France, Germany and Australia. It also blocks some regions, such as Ontario and Quebec in Canada. Its footer says the site "is not regulated by the CFTC and operates independently". Our post on how Polymarket works explains it, and our Polymarket leaderboard shows what its top traders are betting on, ranked by real profit.

Polymarket US is a separate app for people in the US, and you trade in US dollars. Its accounts aren't connected to polymarket.com. Our post on Polymarket in the US has more. Our post on Polymarket vs Kalshi puts the two side by side.

Are prediction markets gambling?

There's no single answer. It depends on who you ask and where you live, and the courts haven't settled it. Here's what each side says:

  • The CFTC says event contracts are typically structured as swaps: financial contracts whose value comes from something else, here the result of an event. In February 2026, its chairman, Michael Selig, wrote that the CFTC alone has authority over these markets.
  • Kalshi says an exchange is not a casino. "Casinos are the counterparty, but exchanges are not," it wrote in August 2026. The counterparty is the one on the other side of your bet. Kalshi says prediction markets earn from trading fees, while sportsbooks earn from losing bets and a fee built into the odds.
  • polymarket.com uses the word betting itself. Its help page says you can profit from your knowledge "by betting on future events". It also says you bet against other users, so there's no house "to ban you for winning too much".
  • Some US states disagree with the CFTC. In the same February article, its chairman wrote that exchanges such as Kalshi and Polymarket faced nearly 50 active court cases. The most common claim, he said, is that these contracts "are a form of gambling and therefore subject to state laws".
  • Some countries treat them as gambling. On 25th February 2026, France's ANJ said prediction sites "are not authorised and are considered illegal gambling services" in France. On 16th July 2026, its president ordered French internet providers to block the Polymarket website. The ANJ says Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands and other countries have blocked Polymarket too.

Are prediction markets legal in the US?

The CFTC says it regulates them under federal law, and has done so since 2004, when it approved the first designated contract market to offer binary options: contracts with a Yes or No result. A designated contract market is the CFTC's name for an exchange that runs under its oversight.

The CFTC says these exchanges must pass a strict application process and face regular checks after that. They must also follow rules meant to stop wrongdoing, such as market manipulation and insider trading. It also says prediction markets "are federally regulated and under federal law can operate in all 50 states".

Not everyone agrees, and the fight is in the courts right now. Here's the record from Reuters, the CFTC and the Supreme Court's own docket:

WhenWhat happened
April 2026A federal appeals court, the 3rd Circuit, said federal law likely overrides New Jersey's gambling laws for Kalshi's sports contracts.
By 11th August 2026The CFTC said it had sued nine states, among them New York and Illinois, to protect its authority.
28th August 2026The 9th Circuit said Kalshi can't stop Nevada's gaming regulators from overseeing its site.
2nd September 2026New Jersey asked the US Supreme Court to overturn the 3rd Circuit's ruling.
25th September 2026The 6th Circuit said Ohio and Tennessee can regulate Kalshi's contracts under their gambling laws. Kalshi said it doesn't expect that ruling to survive further review.

When we read its docket on 7th October 2026, the Supreme Court hadn't said whether it will hear New Jersey's case. Its docket gives Kalshi until 9th November 2026 to respond. This changes fast, so check the rules where you live before you bet.

What are the risks of prediction markets?

The CFTC puts it plainly: "All speculation involves risk." Here are the risks that the CFTC, the platforms and France's ANJ point out:

  • You can lose the whole bet. The CFTC says that if your side loses, you lose what you put in. Fees and taxes can also cut into what you win.
  • You may not be able to sell. Polymarket says you can sell early only if someone is willing to buy your shares. Its docs add that a large order may move the price a lot.
  • The rules decide the result. The CFTC tells you to read each market's rules. It says you're entitled to know what a contract pays, and who decides the result and how.
  • Unregistered sites may protect you less. The CFTC says to trade only with registered platforms. It warns that you may have "little or no protections" with an unregistered one that operates outside the United States.
  • Fake apps and big promises. The CFTC says fake apps sometimes slip into app stores, so check the platform's own website for the link to its real app. It calls promises of big payoffs or free money red flags of a scam.
  • It can turn into a habit. France's ANJ says prediction sites have addictive features, made worse because they lack the protections of legal gambling sites. It says they're open 24 hours a day, with no built-in betting limits and no time limits. Kalshi says it offers trading breaks, self-exclusion and a cap on how much you can deposit.

Please keep in mind

You can lose all the money you bet, so only bet what you can afford to lose. You must be 18 or over, and betting must be legal where you live. Nothing in this post is financial, legal or tax advice.

Where these facts come from

We read these pages on 7th October 2026. Rules and fees change, so check the official page before you act.

Keep reading

All posts
  • Kalshi: How to contact Kalshi support

    Use the support chat in the Kalshi app (menu, Get help, Chat with support) or on kalshi.com. If the chat won't work, Kalshi gives support@kalshi.com. Kalshi says it does not offer phone call or text support at this time.

  • Polymarket: How to contact Polymarket support

    Polymarket offers support by chat on polymarket.com and by email to support@polymarket.com. The help pages we read list no phone number. The Polymarket US app has its own support team, at support@polymarket.us.

  • Kalshi: How long does Kalshi take to pay out?

    Kalshi says most markets settle within a few hours after the result is known, often within about 3 hours. Winning contracts are then paid to your Kalshi cash balance, and a simple Yes or No contract pays $1 if you're right. Some markets take longer while Kalshi waits for official data.